New Bike Conflict In My Stable??

So I’m at a crossroads with my other chariot and not sure what the outcome will be with the rest of my two wheel children. For those who don’t know, I love my cast wheel bonneville and it’s my ‘budget’ tourer I may change. I’m wanting shaft drive, fitted panniers no cloth or shite things, low bike height, over 1000cc, But no four pots.
The only bikes that fits the bill is either bmw r12r or r1150r/rockster but I’ve spotted a r12r ‘classic’ which is on pretty lace wheels and just the job.
This is where things may go wrong by being better than my bonneville, practical, pretty(in my eyes) and better all round.
Conflict in the stables??

 

Now is that present or past tense talk?

 

But but but......
I normally make sure my bikes differ from each other! This is where I feel the problem lies because non are cheap £1000 bikes and the bmw could do a better all over job than the bonneville

 

I had one before the bonneville just to do the alps, it was so pig ugly, but went so well. It’s the rockster that I’ll have this time as it needs to be better looking or r12r Classic

 

Whoops sorry missed the bloody obvious link!!
Hell fire that’s a lot of money as a second bike!

 

Sky hook?

 

Not happy, my brain wants to implode! Can’t believe the conflict going on in my head!
A bike is for pleasure for me these days but it’s just causing big stresses and emotional conflict!!
I feel this bike I’m chasing will push the bonneville out which I truly enjoy in every way. The thing is that I’m a practical person and the bmw r12r really is that, it’s also pretty for one of those as it’s the ‘classic’ model with period paintwork and glorious laced wide rims and quality fitted luggage. It also does everything bloody well, that’s the worst bit and possibly will make me just use one bike and be practical.

It all started with the Chinese budget tourer which I’ve still got but with a minor problem that I can’t solve. It’s the best value for money and works in harmony and complements the bonneville.
But I must admit my man cave is full and having one bike in there would be very relaxing as I sometimes work from home in it.
I JUST DON’T KNOW WHAT TO DO!!?

 

It just makes me think if you get a housemaid that’s as pretty as the wife................
Why bother with the wife.......

But the wife is from the best family..................,,,, (ie this forum!)

 

Does make sense in a way

 

Steve, you’ve hit the nail on the head.
@andyc1 yes I see that and it’s practical
@thebiglad i very much value what you’ve said but by the time I’ve sold both curren bikes I’ll loose the r12r Classic as they are fewand far between

 

So maybe discard the r12r Classic, go down two notches and and older shitter under £2k similar spec r1100s or a k series four pot that I WILL NOT FALL IN LOVE WITH! But is shaft drive and has good luggage!!??